Historical Pastors of Salem Lutheran Church
| The Rev. John Nicholas Hemping | 1835 – 1850 |
| The Rev. C. F. Welden | 1850 – 1851 |
| The Rev. Nathan Yeager | 1852 – 1853 |
| The Rev. Frederick Walz | 1854 – 1864 |
| The Rev. Jeremiah Schindel | 1865 – 1870 |
| The Rev. Thomas Steck | 1870 – 1873 |
| The Rev. Reuben S. Wagner | 1874 – 1881 |
| The Rev. Joseph Hillpot | 1881 – 1889 |
| The Rev. O. E. Pflueger | 1889 – 1902 |
| The Rev. C. F. Kuder | 1903 – 1906 |
| The Rev. H. A. Kunkle | 1907 – 1908 |
| The Rev. E. J. Heilman | 1909 – 1918 |
| The Rev. W. Z. Artz | 1918 – 1964 |
| The Rev. David Hauck | 1964 – 1974 |
| The Rev. Steven D. Dorsett | 1974 – 1983 |
| The Rev. Charles H. Oldland, III | June 1984 – April 2001 |
| The Rev. John C. Schaertel (interim) | April 2001- March 2002 |
| The Rev. Joel Zeiders (interim) | March 2002 – December 2002 |
| The Rev. John C. Schaertel (interim) | January 2003 – October 2003 |
| The Rev. Nancy Weiss | November 2003 – December 2005 |
| The Rev. John C. Schaertel (interim emeritus) | January 2006 – April 2009 |
| The Rev. Dr. Nathan C. Minnich, STS (emeritus) | April 2009 – April 2022 |
| The Rev. Mark A. Hoffman, STS (pilot unification) | 2022 |
| The Rev. Rodney Lilley (interim) | February 2023 – present |